When does a 1% difference equal $1.5 billion? You’d be surprised, but small percentage differences have and will continue to affect past, current and future electricity bills across New England. Specifically, for one key cost included in electricity bills—the cost of transmission, the system of high-voltage power lines that moves electricity from where it is generated to where it is needed—recent rulings and proposals have called into question just how much consumers ought to be paying to build that regional system.

Simply put, transmission owners—the investor-owned utilities that earn a financial return on the power lines they develop and ow—have been earning more than their fair share on their transmission investments. This is what Acadia Center and other advocates originally argued back in 2012 in a petition challenging transmission owners’ return on equity or “ROE”—the rate transmission owners earn to pay back their investors and turn a profit.

Last March, after 14 years of legal wrangling, the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission (FERC), which regulates transmission, reduced New England transmission owners’ ROE by 1%. The ruling, which applied retroactively back to the year of the petition, found that transmission owners had been overcharging ratepayers, and required them to refund $1.5 billion in over-collections, including interest. The Commission’s ruling accepted the argument central to the 2012 petition: that regional transmission rates were not “just and reasonable.”

At a time of concern over costs and affordability, $1.5 billion is no small number.

Yet rather than working to ensure that the 7.2 million New England electricity customers receive the $1.5 billion they’re owed, transmission owners moved swiftly instead to delay payment of the refund and appealed the ruling. Then the transmission owners took the additional step of asking FERC to increase their just-reduced ROE, and their future profits. The transmission owners doubled down on their push for higher earnings, responding to FERC’s retroactive 1% rate reduction with a proposed rate increase of nearly 2% that would apply to future spending. That 2% increase, together with related adders, would increase transmission owner’s ROE to 11.89%, and cost ratepayers an estimated $270-$300 million every year.

The transmission owners claim that they’re simply utilizing FERC’s own formula to derive the proposed 2% increase, but there’s strong consensus opposing the method transmission owners used to calculate the higher rate—New England states, consumer advocates, nonprofits, and large-scale energy users have all filed protests at FERC opposing the transmission owners’ request for increased earnings. Acadia Center has submitted expert testimony to FERC concluding that the transmission owners’ rate proposal is based on selectively chosen values that erroneously inflate the rate—and transmission owners’ bottom lines. The expert testimony further concluded that an accurate application of FERC’s formula would produce a rate of 9.31% – more than 2% below the transmission owners’ proposed rate.

This is a critical juncture: FERC’s decision on the transmission owners’ updated proposal is anticipated in the coming weeks and will establish how much electricity customers will have to pay moving forward for transmission. Over the next twenty-five years, the total cost of needed transmission investments will range from between $16 to $26 billion dollars. The 11.89% all-in rate proposed by the transmission owners would increase the cost of those investments, and electricity customers’ bills, significantly relative to the status quo.

What’s more, recent analysis from Acadia Center and Clean Air Task Force suggests that using another financing structure entirely—public financing sources offered by states—will reap even deeper consumer savings relative to the region’s status quo of transmission investment. Replacing higher cost private equity and debt with cheaper, tax-exempt public debt and equity have the potential to reduce the cost of the region’s new transmission needs by up to 43%, or close to $10 billion – a total that would only grow relative to the new higher rate of return proposed by the transmission owners, to the tune of billions of dollars over time.

During a period of acute energy affordability issues, efforts to delay refund payments and seek future increases will only lead to more waiting and more costs for customers. Let’s be clear: appropriate transmission investments are critical to meeting the region’s future goals, but they must be funded in a manner that provides adequate and not excessive profits. Consumer interests must be at the forefront of this issue. And the affordability of the region’s investments to build-out and optimize its transmission grid will have major implications for deployments of renewable energy, the economics of electrification, and the broader public support for the energy transition.

It’s important for policymakers, consumer advocates, and stakeholders to be aware of the situation and prepared for the impending FERC Order. With new, low-cost financing solutions on the table, the region can build more transmission for less while reducing consumers; cost burden. New England’s electricity customers deserve nothing less than the least cost path to achieving the region’s critical goals of affordability, reliability, and decarbonization, all of which can be addressed with smart transmission investment.